Table of Content

  • Before coffee: Guatemala's indigo empire
    • A gamble on insects
      • From Jesuit gardens to the export market
        • How Barrios built a coffee state
          • The cost to Guatemala's indigenous communities
            • The coffee we buy from Guatemala today

                How the collapse of natural dyes built Guatemala's coffee industry

                From indigo to cochineal to coffee: how Guatemala’s dye trade set the pattern for its coffee industry.

                Saskia Chapman Gibbs 7 min read
                How the collapse of natural dyes built Guatemala's coffee industry

                Table of Contents

                • Before coffee: Guatemala's indigo empire
                  • A gamble on insects
                    • From Jesuit gardens to the export market
                      • How Barrios built a coffee state
                        • The cost to Guatemala's indigenous communities
                          • The coffee we buy from Guatemala today

                              In 1850, almost all of Guatemala's export earnings came from crushed insects. Cochineal, a red dye made from scale insects that live on cactus, made up 93% of the country's exports. Thirty years later, coffee had taken its place, accounting for 92% of exports by 1880.

                              That switch is often told as a simple story of one crop replacing another. But Guatemala's coffee industry was built on patterns that stretched back to its colonial dye trade: an export economy dependent on a single crop, a state that stepped in to secure land and workers for growers, and indigenous communities who bore the cost.

                              Before coffee: Guatemala's indigo empire

                              Long before coffee, and even before cochineal, Spanish Guatemala ran on indigo. The dye came from a plant called xiquilite, whose properties were already known to the Maya, and from the 17th century onwards indigo exports paid for most of what the colony imported. At its peak, two million pesos' worth left the kingdom every year. The plantations stretched along the Pacific coastal plain, from the north-west of today's Guatemala to Lake Nicaragua, and much of the dye was grown in what is now El Salvador.

                              Indigo also set the pattern for how the region's export crops would be worked. As early as the 1500s, Spain banned the use of indigenous workers in indigo production because the work was so harmful, but for nearly two centuries growers ignored the ban and simply paid the fines. In 1636, a colonial court condemned the greed of Spaniards who used fraud and force to make indigenous people work, and seized their land to plant indigo. The ban was finally lifted in 1738, and in 1784 a new ordinance allowed up to a quarter of the able-bodied men in a village to be drafted onto indigo estates, with lashing as the punishment for those who failed to turn up. Many growers, meanwhile, were deeply in debt to the merchants who financed their crops.

                              By the end of the 18th century, the indigo trade was in decline. Locust plagues, heavy taxes and competition from Caracas, India and the Dutch East Indies all took their toll, and after peaking at around 1.3 million pounds a year in the early 1790s, production fell sharply in the two decades before independence. After independence in 1821, El Salvador, which grew most of the region's indigo, went its own way, and Guatemala's economy languished.

                              A gamble on insects

                              In the 1840s and 1850s, Guatemala's exports recovered on the back of a new dye. Cochineal, made from the bodies of insects that live on nopal cacti, could be very profitable in a good year, but it was a gamble: a short rain shower at the wrong moment or an unexpected cold snap could ruin a whole year's work.

                              By the middle of the century, the gamble was getting worse. Harvests were poor, and the invention of synthetic aniline dyes in Europe cut demand for natural ones. At the same time, Guatemala could see its neighbour Costa Rica building a successful coffee export trade. Coffee had clear advantages over cochineal: it could be grown across much more of the country, it was less perishable, and it was cheaper to transport over long distances.

                              From Jesuit gardens to the export market

                              Coffee wasn't new to Guatemala. It had been growing in the Jesuits' botanical gardens in Antigua since at least the 1740s, and in 1747, senior officials of the colony tasted it as a drink for the first time, at a banquet. Spain had also tried to encourage it: late in the colonial period, coffee growers who brought new land into cultivation were given the same tax breaks as indigo growers.

                              The real push came in the middle of the 19th century. After 1845, private individuals joined the government in urging farmers to plant coffee. In the 1850s and 1860s, led by the government-subsidised Economic Society of the Friends of the Country, a few landowners and indigenous communities began to experiment with it, sometimes planting it among their cochineal. It wasn't easy. Techniques that worked in Colombia and Costa Rica didn't always suit Guatemala's soils and climate, and several early efforts ended in disaster.

                              Still, coffee caught on fast. It made up just 1% of Guatemala's exports in 1860, but by 1871 it accounted for half.

                              How Barrios built a coffee state

                              The turning point came in 1871, when the Liberal Revolution brought General Justo Rufino Barrios to power. Barrios was a coffee planter himself, and the rise of coffee that followed has been described as the most fundamental change to Guatemala's institutions since the Spanish conquest. His government encouraged investment in railways, roads and telegraphs, founded the country's first agricultural bank and set about opening up the countryside to coffee growers.

                              The land came first. In 1873, certain coastal lands were declared uncultivated and put up for sale at low, fixed prices, even though several communities claimed them. In 1877, Decree 170 ended a long-standing form of land tenure under which farmers held the right to use land in exchange for an annual payment. Tenants who had the right to use their land but no formal title were given only a short time to buy it, and in the decades that followed, large areas of indigenous communal land were lost to coffee.

                              Then came the workers. Coffee needed huge numbers of hands, and its expansion was held back above all by a shortage of labour. Also in 1877, Decree 177 legalised debt peonage, which tied workers to estates through debt, and brought back the mandamiento: a labour draft under which local officials had to supply workers to export growers.

                              The results were dramatic. By 1880, coffee accounted for 92% of Guatemala's export value, and between 1870 and 1890 the government almost tripled its operating budget and nearly quintupled its spending on war.

                              The cost to Guatemala's indigenous communities

                              The cost fell mostly on Guatemala's indigenous majority. Some communities tried to escape the demands for their labour by moving elsewhere in the country, crossing into Mexico or Belize, or fleeing into the wilderness. The picture wasn't one of total dispossession, though. The Liberal regime never abolished community property altogether, partly because indigenous villages were also where coffee growers found their seasonal workers, and historians have argued that Barrios's government was more hesitant about privatising land than is often claimed. Many communities lost part of their land rather than all of it.

                              Forced labour outlasted the 19th century. The mandamiento was abolished in 1894, but in 1934 a vagrancy law brought in under President Jorge Ubico again made workers, especially indigenous ones, liable to forced labour at critical times of year. Two decades later, a land reform that hit the US-owned United Fruit Company hard became one of the issues behind the coup of 1954, which forced President Jacobo Árbenz from office.

                              The imbalance the coffee boom created has never fully gone away. By the end of the 20th century, 65% of Guatemala's farmland was owned by just 2% of the population.

                              The coffee we buy from Guatemala today

                              Guatemala's coffee story began with large estates built on indigenous land and labour, but some of the coffee we buy from there today comes from small producers. Hunbatz, for example, is a community of small producers farming the slopes of Cuilco in Huehuetenango, and Hunchouen is a collective of 550 small producers in the same region.

                              You can explore our current Guatemalan coffees to taste what those producers are growing today.

                              Frequently Asked Questions

                              When did coffee arrive in Guatemala?

                              Coffee was growing in the Jesuits’ gardens in Antigua by at least the 1740s, and senior officials of the colony first tasted it as a drink at a banquet in 1747. It only became a serious export crop in the 1850s and 1860s.

                              What did Guatemala export before coffee?

                              Natural dyes. In the colonial era, indigo paid for most of the colony’s imports, and at its peak two million pesos’ worth was exported every year. By the 1840s and 1850s, Guatemala’s economy relied on cochineal, a red dye made from insects that live on cactus. In 1850, cochineal made up 93% of Guatemala’s exports.

                              Why did Guatemala switch from cochineal to coffee?

                              Cochineal was risky, as a badly timed rain shower or cold snap could ruin a year’s work. By the mid-1800s, harvests were poor, and the invention of synthetic aniline dyes in Europe had cut demand for natural ones. Coffee could be grown across more of the country, was less perishable and was cheaper to transport.

                              How did coffee affect Guatemala’s indigenous communities?

                              Laws passed in 1873 and 1877 opened up land claimed by indigenous communities to coffee growers. A law of 1877 legalised debt peonage and brought back the mandamiento, a forced labour draft that supplied workers to coffee estates. Many communities lost part of their land, and some people fled to Mexico, Belize or remote areas to escape the demands on their labour.

                              Saskia Chapman Gibbs

                              Marketing & Sustainability, Green Coffee Collective

                              Saskia leads Communications and Sourcing at Green Coffee Collective. She holds an MSc in Global Development and specialises in geopolitics and inequality within specialty coffee, including research on third wave coffee and value chain addition in Guatemala.